On Seamonkey

Some time ago someone on this newsgroup kindly told me about XUL Runner 
<http://wiki.mozilla.org/XUL:Xul_Runner>.

I've just had another quick look at the page I just referred to: seems 
to be no mention of making XUL Runner a core technology for Firefox and 
Thunderbird.

If XUL Runner did become a core technology for Firefox and Thunderbird 
then the people using these programs would only need one Gecko runtime 
loaded into memory no matter how many XUL+XPCOM(*) applications they're 
running simultaneously.

So wouldn't that be just about it for the Seamonkey project if that 
happened, given that with separate apps Firefox & Thunderbird it's 
easier to do releases? Or are there strong other reasons that some 
people prefer and integrated suite?

(*)If you ask me what this is I would be likely to dribble and cry.
0
Sean
12/10/2005 8:54:19 AM
netscape.mozilla.seamonkey 1248 articles. 0 followers. Follow

4 Replies
518 Views

Similar Articles

[PageSpeed] 49

Sean Vickery (remove the blood-smeared Nordics to email) aber hob zu
reden an und schrieb:
> If XUL Runner did become a core technology for Firefox and Thunderbird 
> then the people using these programs would only need one Gecko runtime 
> loaded into memory no matter how many XUL+XPCOM(*) applications they're 
> running simultaneously.
> 
> So wouldn't that be just about it for the Seamonkey project if that 
> happened, given that with separate apps Firefox & Thunderbird it's 
> easier to do releases?

No, why should it?

> Or are there strong other reasons that some people prefer and
integrated suite?

Making FF/TB run as XULRunner applications would "just" be a background
change, you still would lack the tight integration of the components as
found in SeaMonkey, and their look and feel would still be different
from SeaMonkey...

Furthermore, we do strive to make SeaMonkey become a XULRunner app also
(even though we're not sure yet if this is possible without losing too
much of SeaMonkey's distinctive likeness).


Karsten
-- 
       Freiheit stirbt        |       Fsayannes SF&F-Bibliothek:
            Mit Sicherheit    |       http://fsayanne.tprac.de/
0
ISO
12/10/2005 3:14:11 PM
Karsten D�sterloh wrote:

> Sean Vickery (remove the blood-smeared Nordics to email) aber hob zu 
> reden an und schrieb:
>> Or are there strong other reasons that some people prefer and 
>> integrated suite?
> 
> Making FF/TB run as XULRunner applications would "just" be a 
> background change [..]

Well, true, it would be a technical change--"background" if you
like--but the user would have the benefits of quicker application
loading times (for the second and subquent invocations of XUL Runner 
apps after restart).

> [..] you still would lack the tight integration of the components as
> found in SeaMonkey [..]



I think there's another approach to integration that would work just as
well as Seamonkey's approach: making more extensive use of URLs (of a
wide variety of schemes) and MIME-types in the intercommunication
between Firefox, Thunderbird, Sunbird/(Calendar), etc.

MS Windows XP (the OS I'm presently most familiar with) provides the
facility to invoke the user's preferred application on an object
provided a file type, MIME-type or URL-scheme is available.

Examples:

A Thunderbird user clicks on a HTTP URL in an email message: Thunderbird
gets Windows to invoke the user's preferred web browser on the URL,
bringing up a browser window displaying the resource located by the URL.

A Sunbird(Calendar) user might click on an email address (mailto URL) in
a calendar entry: Sunbird gets Windows to invoke the user's preferred
mail client on the mailto URL, bringing up an email composition window
with the recipient and possibly other fields already filled in.

A Firefox user browsing an organisation's webpage with an online
calendar of events clicks on a link describing a seminar in the iCal
(text/calendar MIME-type) format: Firefox gets Windows to invoke the
user's preferrer calendar program which creates a dialog window the let
the user enter the seminar into their diary.

I can think of further examples.

This architectural approach allows applications to "hand off" any number
of different types of object to the appropriate other application,
without requiring one monolithic application which is hard to release.

No doubt this architectural consideration is one of the major reasons
(most of) the Mozilla team decided to go with the Firefox/Thunderbird
approach.

> [..] and their look and feel would still be different from
> SeaMonkey...

Well yeah, no arguing with you about that.
0
Sean
12/11/2005 4:47:57 PM
Sean Vickery (remove the blood-smeared Nordics to email) wrote:
> I think there's another approach to integration that would work just as
> well as Seamonkey's approach: making more extensive use of URLs (of a
> wide variety of schemes) and MIME-types in the intercommunication
> between Firefox, Thunderbird, Sunbird/(Calendar), etc.

> A Thunderbird user clicks on a HTTP URL in an email message: Thunderbird
> gets Windows to invoke the user's preferred web browser on the URL,
> bringing up a browser window displaying the resource located by the URL.

What if a Thunderbird user clicks "submit" on an HTML form in an email message?  ;)

> I can think of further examples.

So can I, but there are times when one needs to pass large amounts of data 
around; URLs are very ill-suited for that.

> This architectural approach allows applications to "hand off" any number
> of different types of object

As long as each object is small.

-Boris
0
Boris
12/11/2005 5:30:52 PM
Boris Zbarsky wrote:
> [..] There are times when one needs to pass large amounts of 
> data around; URLs are very ill-suited for that.

Yes, I don't think URLs are good for that. But this is when I think MIME 
can come more into play. Application #1 sees a MIME object and copies 
it, perhaps to a temporary file or shared memory, and passes it to 
Application #2. E.g., this is what Firefox does when it invokes Windows 
Media Player on an MP3 music file. In fact Firefox (and of course 
Seamonkey) can have any number of helper applications registered and.

I know there are deficiencies in Thunderbird's ability to be invoked 
with URLs (it doesn't support the mid: or cid: schemes (see 
<ftp://ftp.rfc-editor.org/in-notes/rfc2392.txt> and 
<https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=264270>).

Thunderbird has problems with attached message/rfc822 messages 
(interestingly perhaps these problems have recently been fixed in 
Seamonkey <https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=241213>). So I 
doubt it behaves sensible when invoked upon a message/rfc822 object.

The barrier to integration between diverse applications, the 
architecture I am arguing in favour of here, is the lack of (especially 
non-Mozilla) applications that support sophisticated invocations from 
another app. By 'sophisticated' I mean that the invoked app does more 
than just start: it starts in a context set for it by the invoking app.

> Sean Vickery (remove the blood-smeared Nordics to email) wrote:
>> This architectural approach allows applications to "hand off" any number
>> of different types of object
> 
> As long as each object is small.

Depends on the how the hand offs are implemented.
0
Sean
12/12/2005 2:36:43 PM
Reply:

Similar Artilces:

Having problems with "Threads with Unread" in mozilla.support.seamonkey on news.mozilla.org in SeaMonkey v1.06.
Hello, I seem to have found another problem after uninstalling Mozilla v1.7.13 (kept my profiles and did not delete my Mozilla folder/directory to copy the extensions and plugins) and installing SeaMonkey v1.06 last night in Windows XP Pro. SP2 (all updates). 2 screen shots: http://img132.imageshack.us/img132/9589/mozillasupportseamonkeyec0.gif .... I can't seem to make "Threads with Unread" work in mozilla.support.seamonkey newsgroup on news.mozilla.org news server. I tried unsubscribing, resubscribing, changing options, compacting (compact if 100+ KB in se...

Importing Seamonkey to Seamonkey.
I'm sure it's simple. but I can't figure out how to import all settings, address book, bookmarks. accounts from one drive to another on the same Mac. I'm switching boot from one drive to another. Can you help? Thanks. John Sipos Broadcast talk journalist 727-432-1322 John Sipos wrote: > I'm sure it's simple. but I can't figure out how to import all settings, > address book, bookmarks. accounts from one drive to another on the same > Mac. I'm switching boot from one drive to another. Can you help? Thanks. > > John Sipos &...

SeaMonkey
Sort of like 'Where's Waldo'[1] ... See how many clicks & pages it takes you to find the SeaMonkey pages. https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/ Nope. Not there. https://www.mozilla.org/en-US/products/ Nope. Not there. SeaMonkey isn't a "Product". Hint: You can indeed get to a page with SeaMonkey on it from there... see how easy it is for you to find it. When you do get to the page, SeaMonkey is spelled 'Seamonkey'. Not only do Mozilla dis SeaMonkey by hiding it three obscure pages in, but then they spell it with a lowercase 'm'. My we ...

SeaMonkey or Mozilla
I have an old configuration with Windows 98. If we ignore security problems. Do you think that Mozilla 1.7.13 is better than SeaMonkey 1.1.8 ? 1.7 is the stable branch and I think 1.8 is not. Is it better to use Mozilla 1.7.13 for the stability ? What do you think ? Thank you very much. JR wrote: > I have an old configuration with Windows 98. > If we ignore security problems. > Do you think that Mozilla 1.7.13 is better than SeaMonkey 1.1.8 ? > 1.7 is the stable branch and I think 1.8 is not. > Is it better to use Mozilla 1.7.13 for the stability ? > What do you...

Mozilla seamonkey
http://www.mozilla.org/seamonkey-transition.html Think this must be the worst news the I have read from mozilla.org. I cannot see why you are doing this becouse sea-monkey is the base of the mozilla.org it was therefor it was started in the first place. If I remeber correctly. I prefer seamonkey over firefox along way. alphadec wrote: > http://www.mozilla.org/seamonkey-transition.html > > Think this must be the worst news the I have read from mozilla.org. > > I cannot see why you are doing this becouse sea-monkey is the base of > the mozilla.org it ...

Mozilla Seamonkey
Will seamonkey be pursued beyond 1.0 alpha 1? On 11/30/2005 10:25 pm, Zachary thus wrote : > Will seamonkey be pursued beyond 1.0 alpha 1? > Latest trunk is 1.5a. The 1.0 beta is also available. SeaMonkey is a current, active project, gaining users regularly. In fact, I find rendering to be much faster with SeaMonkey than FF, and prefer an integrated suite vs the separate apps (many people do). Grab a nightly build and enjoy. And please don't forget to post feedback and bug reports (if necessary). -- Lewis -----------------------------------------------------...

From Mozilla to SeaMonkey
How do I go from Mozilla 1.7.12 to SeaMonkey 1.1.1? What can I transfer from the old to the new suite? Would it be wise to keep Mozilla for a while? I�ll appreciate any help in this matter. Monica// Monica wrote: > How do I go from Mozilla 1.7.12 to SeaMonkey 1.1.1? > What can I transfer from the old to the new suite? > > Would it be wise to keep Mozilla for a while? > > I�ll appreciate any help in this matter. > > Monica// all your settings, prefs, bookmarks, mail, etc, are stored in an area called the Profile. When you install SM, it will ...

SeaMonkey or Mozilla
I have an old configuration with Windows 98. If we ignore security problems. Do you think that Mozilla 1.7.13 is better than SeaMonkey 1.1.8 ? 1.7 is the stable branch and I think 1.8 is not. Is it better to use Mozilla 1.7.13 for the stability ? What do you think ? Thank you very much. JR wrote: > I have an old configuration with Windows 98. > If we ignore security problems. > Do you think that Mozilla 1.7.13 is better than SeaMonkey 1.1.8 ? > 1.7 is the stable branch and I think 1.8 is not. > Is it better to use Mozilla 1.7.13 for the stability ? > What do you...

SeaMonkey
Name: Colin Peel Email: peel_at_univ-perp.fr Product: Other (please state) Summary: SeaMonkey Comments: This latest build is fast, relatively reliable (it gets bogged down on occasions, but less often). On the other hand, it's nuts. You ask it to suppress an article, and it tries to download it. Browser Details: Mozilla/5.0 (Macintosh; U; PPC Mac OS X Mach-O; en-US; rv:1.9a1) Gecko/20060130 SeaMonkey/1.5a ...

SeaMonkey
Name: Robert Nolan Email: robert_nolan_at_hotmail.com Product: Other (please state) Summary: SeaMonkey Comments: SeaMonkey does not give me the option to import bookmarks from Opera. Bugzilla does not let me log in to submit comments like this. Browser Details: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows; U; Windows NT 5.1; en-US; rv:1.8) Gecko/20051219 SeaMonkey/1.0b ...

Seamonkey
I've been playing with SeaMonkey V2 beta. It had an irritating problem with its newsreader personality (trailing dot buffer parsing I'd guess). Anyway, Dennis has posted the latest version 1.1.18. It doesn't have this problem. When trying to incorporate some addons, the process is not nearly so obvious as in the Version 2 or FF3.5 but at least the parsing fault is missing. Trying to add NoScript. No problem Trying to add Adblock plus. Message = 'No install script found' The ABP site lists ABP for Seamonkey for Version 2. No mention of earlier(s) Surely cannot be...

SeaMonkey
I am trying to build a new website with SeaMonkey. All has worked well and I have built 15 pages, however, I have started to see that sometimes when I open some pages, there are several images that have disappeared from their relevant box. This problem seems to have started, after being advised to have all my images in the html folder in SeaMonkey, so I dragged them over from my file in my computer and dropped them into the same file as my web pages. Now sometimes I have a full page of images (Photos) and sometimes a number of them are missing. Please help me. Marcel ...

Seamonkey
Is it appropriate to ask Seamonkey-related questions here? If so, how do I import bookmarks from Firefox and email accounts from Thunderbird? Thanks. -- Pete Holsberg Columbus, NJ -- To be able under all circumstances to practice five things constitutes perfect virtue; these five things are gravity, generosity of soul, sincerity, earnestness and kindness. Confucius Pete Holsberg wrote: > Is it appropriate to ask Seamonkey-related questions here? > > If so, how do I import bookmarks from Firefox and email accounts from > Thunderbird? > > Thanks....

Seamonkey
Is there any hacks to get Seamonkey to work with Calendar? ...

Seamonkey
Is there any way to export to Seamonkey the emails and account setting I have in TB? J On Mon, 19 Nov 2007 08:43:44 -0500, Jeffinputnam wrote: > Is there any way to export to Seamonkey the emails and account setting I > have in TB? > > J Go to your TB profile which will be somewhere like C:\Documents and Settings\Yourname\Application Data\Thunderbird\Profiles\default.bci (Best to make a copy of it at this point) then copy the folder called MAIL the go to your SB profile at C:\Documents and Settings\Yourname\Application Data\Mozilla\Profiles\default\anumber....

Web resources about - On Seamonkey - netscape.mozilla.seamonkey

The Hawaiian Seamonkey
Diving, eating, gardening, loving the Big Island of Hawaii

The SeaMonkey® Project
The SeaMonkey project is a community effort to develop the SeaMonkeyall-in-one internet application suite (see below).Such a software suite was ...

SeaMonkey - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
cross-platform Internet suite . It is the continuation of the former Mozilla Application Suite , based on the same source code. Core Mozilla ...

Review: SeaMonkey 1.1.8 for the Mac
SeaMonkey 1.1.8, the Mozilla Foundation's all-in-one Internet application, combines browsing, e-mail, HTML editing, and IRC chat.

SeaMonkey 2.3 Beta 1 arrives for testing
Based on the same Gecko browser engine as Firefox 6, SeaMonkey 2.3 Beta 1 has been released for testing. It offers improvements to WebGL that ...

SeaMonkey Offers Browser, E-Mail, and Chat
... resuscitated a group of Internet tools built by Netscapewhose spin-off, Mozilla, brought out the popular Firefox Web browser. Renamed SeaMonkey ...

SeaMonkey, Mozilla's all-in-one Internet suite, releases new beta
The SeaMonkey Project has released SeaMonkey 2.1 Beta 3 , a version that makes a lot of new functionality available to a wide audience for the ...

SeaMonkey review
Browse the web, work with mail, chat in IRC and edit HTML

SeaMonkey 2.33
... advanced e-mail, newsgroup and feed client, IRC chat, and HTML editing made simple, all your Internet needs in one application. The SeaMonkey ...

Seamonkey 1.1 Released
stuuf writes "Version 1.1 of the Seamonkey Internet Application Suite is now available, with quite a few improvements over the 1.0 series. Some ...

Resources last updated: 1/16/2016 3:10:40 PM